Are Cats Omnivores? An Honest Look at Vegan Cat Food

Food & Nutrition | Cat

Veganism and plant-based diets are quickly growing in popularity, but is a diet that is suitable for you suitable for your cat too? To find out, we need to ask: Are cats omnivores, and is it possible for a plant-based diet to meet their nutritional needs?

In this article, we will look at the difference between omnivores and carnivores, look into the dietary needs of cats, and take a peak into the world of vegan cat foods to give you all the facts you need to choose the best diet for your feline friend.

Let’s dive in.

What is an Omnivore?

raw-meat-vegetables-food-dog-cat

An omnivore is an animal that can survive on both plant and animal sources. You are an omnivore. Bears are omnivores. Omnivores are physically designed for chewing, digesting, and synthesizing nutrients from both plant and animal-based foods.

This is evident in both our teeth and our digestive system. An omnivore has broader, flatter molars to grind and chew plant materials. They also have sharp pointed canine teeth to allow for tearing flesh.

Most omnivores also produce the digestive enzyme amylase in their saliva to kick start the breakdown of carbohydrates. Without salivary amylase, the pancreas must work hard to produce enough of the enzyme to breakdown carbs.  

Carnivores do not have the same capacity for breaking down plant materials because they don't produce salivary amylase. They also have sharp serrated molars that slice flesh like scissors, and a wide-set jaw designed to swallow large chunks of meat.

Carnivores have a more acidic stomach environment, too. This allows for faster and more efficient break down of meat and even bone.  

When comparing the digestive system of an omnivore to a carnivore, there are some obvious physical differences, too.

Omnivores have a smaller stomach capacity and a longer small intestinal tract that allow for the breakdown of higher quantities of plant materials, where as carnivores have a large acidic stomach that can quickly process animal ingredients and allow for quick digestion through a shorter intestinal tract. 

Are Cats Omnivores?

Nope. Cats are not omnivores. They may have adapted to eating plant-heavy commercial pet foods, but that doesn't change their biology.

Biologically, cats are carnivores - obligate carnivores to be precise. This means that some of the nutrients they require can only be sourced naturally from animal protein.  

Without animal protein in their diet, they would be missing vital nutrients that will negatively affect their health.

Knowing this, we have to question whether or not the emerging trend of plant-based cat diets is actually appropriate. Can cats survive on a vegetarian or vegan diet? And if they can, will they thrive the same as they would on a meat-inclusive diet?

The answer is an unsatisfactory - maybe. To help breakdown both sides of this debate, let’s talk about the unique dietary requirements of cats.

Dietary Requirements of Cats

cat-eating-food-bowl

We already went over the most apparent carnivorous traits of cats, but it goes even further. How they digest their food, from teeth to tail, is designed to accommodate a meat-based diet, right down to the nutrients that their bodies can synthesize and create on their own.

Some nutrients are essential, meaning they must acquire them from their diet, while others are non-essential. They are able to make some quantities of non-essential nutrients by breaking down or synthesizing other nutrients.

Amino Acids

The most notable essential nutrient for cats is the amino acid, taurine. Taurine is vital for heart and eye health and aids in bile production, which is required for digestion.

The only food sources of taurine are meat, fish, and eggs. In a plant-based diet, synthetic, or man-made taurine must be used. We will touch more on synthetic nutrients later.

In defence of a vegan diet, most other amino acids can be sourced from plant material. Arginine, for example, is abundantly found in meat but can also be sourced from grains and legumes. The quantity and digestibility of the nutrient will vary depending on the source, but the right mix of plant ingredients should meet a cat's dietary needs of many essential nutrients. 

Omega Fatty Acids

Essential fatty acids are a type of functional fat. Functional fats play a crucial role in regular bodily functions, like muscle development, hormone production, and cell cycles. Most omega fatty acids can be sourced from plants, too. Plants like flax, sunflower, and canola offer a wide variety of omega fatty acids.

So, what’s the problem?

Well, not all omega fatty acids are abundantly available from plant sources. Some are either best or only sourced from fish and fish oils. The prime example of this is DHA (docosahexaenoic acid).

Cats can synthesize DHA from another omega fatty acid called ALA (alpha-linolenic acid), which can be sourced from plants, but only about 20% of ALA can be successfully converted to DHA. This means that dietary supplementation is still needed.

Though this omega 3 fatty acid is primarily sourced from fish and fish oils, it can also be found in certain types of marine algae, but not as abundantly as in fish.

Synthetic Nutrients

vitamin-nutrient-powder-supplement

So if some nutrients can't be sourced from plants, and others can only be sourced in a limited capacity, then how can a plant-based diet meet a cat's nutritional needs?

This is where synthetic or man-made nutrients come into play. Synthetic ingredients are very commonly used in pet products, and for the most part, are necessary for a processed pet diet, like kibble or canned foods, to be considered complete and balanced.

Synthetic nutrients, in most cases, provide similar levels of nutrients as their food or natural counterparts, but here’s where it gets tricky.

Some synthetic nutrients, while identical on paper, may not be perfectly equal to their food counterparts once they are processed and digested. Here are some things to consider about synthetic nutrients:

Complete and Balanced Plant-Based Cat Food

Considering what we've learned, let's circle back to the original question:

Are cats omnivores?

I hope we've made it pretty clear that, no, cats are not omnivores. You can take the meat out of their diet, but you can't change their biology. 

Are plant-based diets are suitable for cats? 

Meeting AAFCO nutrient profiles for cats using only plant-based ingredients and synthetic nutrients is possible. Just like any other recipe, you add a little of this to buffer that, and… ta-da! You have cat food.

In an interesting article from Vecado, a vegan pet food brand, they thoroughly compared two diets, one plant-based and one meat-based. It shows many similarities in nutrient profiles. The use of synthetic ingredients was similar in both examples arguing the fact that there really isn't much difference between the nutrition in meat-based and plant-based formulas. 

It also points out the harmful consequences of the meat industry, namely the slaughter of animals and the greenhouse gas emissions associated with the industry. They make a pretty compelling argument, we'll admit, but we wanted to take a run at it using a slightly different approach. 

While this comparison helped show that vegan diets can meet AAFCO definitions of complete and balanced, much in the same way that many meat-based pet foods can, we did see one glaring issue with the comparison: Quality. The meat-based diet used in their comparison was sub-par at best. 

Much of our nutritional philosophy is based on offering the right balance of natural food ingredients to provide the best nutrition for your unique cat. While we don’t necessarily believe that a plant-based diet for cats will meet our nutritional standards, we also see many cheaply made meat-based diets that fall short too.

Instead of using the low-quality meat-based diet used in Vecado’s article, we decided to make a comparison that fits better with our nutritional philosophy when it comes to the dietary needs of cats.

Let us know if you can see the difference between the two breakdowns.

Plant-Based vs Meat-Based Cat Diets

 

NS ORIJEN Cat & Kitten Cat Front Right 5.4kg

Orijen Cat & Kitten
(Meat-Based Formula)

vecado-evolution-gourmet-fondue-cat-vegan-2

Vecado Evolution Diet Gourmet Fondue
(Plant-Based Formula)

Animal Sources

·         Fresh Chicken Meat

·         Fresh Turkey Meat

·         Fresh Whole Eggs

·         Fresh Chicken Liver

·         Fresh Whole Flounder

·         Fresh Whole Herring

·         Fresh Turkey Liver

·         Fresh Chicken Heart

·         Fresh Turkey Heart

·         Fresh Chicken Necks

·         Chicken (dehydrated)

·         Turkey (dehydrated)

·         Whole Mackerel (dehydrated)

·         Whole Sardine (dehydrated)

·         Whole Herring (dehydrated)

·         Chicken Fat

·         Herring Oil

·         Chicken Liver (freeze-dried)

·         Turkey Liver (freeze-dried)

N/A

Plant Sources

·        Whole Red Lentils

·         Whole Green Peas

·         Whole Green Lentils

·         Whole Chickpeas

·         Whole Yellow Peas

·         Lentil Fibre

·         Whole Pinto Beans

·         Whole Navy Beans

·         Chicken Cartilage

·         Fresh Whole Pumpkin

·         Fresh Whole Butternut Squash

·         Fresh Whole Zucchini

·         Fresh Whole Parsnips

·         Fresh Carrots

·         Fresh Whole Red Delicious Apples

·         Fresh Whole Bartlett Pears

·         Fresh Kale

·         Fresh Spinach

·         Fresh Beet Greens

·         Fresh Turnip Greens

·         Brown Kelp

·         Whole Cranberries

·         Whole Blueberries

·         Whole Saskatoon Berries

·         Chicory Root

·         Turmeric Root

·         Milk Thistle

·         Burdock Root

·         Lavender

·         Marshmallow Root

·         Rosehips

·         Whole Grain Oatmeal

·         High Protein Maize (Corn) Gluten Meal

·         High Protein Soybean Meal

·         Pea Protein

·         Potato Flakes

·         Molasses

·         Yeast

·         Rosemary Extract

·         Yucca Schidigera Extract

·         Kelp Meal

Synthetic Additives

(Made in a Lab)

N/A

·         Dicalcium Phosphate

·         DL-Methionine

·         Phosphoric Acid

·         Taurine

·         L-Lysine

·         Potassium Chloride

·         Choline Chlorine

·         L-Carnitine

·         Micro-Encapsulated Vitamin C

·         Iron Proteinate

·         Zinc Proteinate

·         Copper Proteinate

·         Manganese Proteinate

·         Cobalt Proteinate

·         Magnesium Proteinate

·         Ferrous Sulfate

·         Zinc Sulfate

·         Zinc Oxide

·         Copper Sulfate

·         Manganous Oxide

·         Sodium Selenite

·         Calcium Iodate

·         Cobalt Carbonate

·         Salt

·         Vitamin A Acetate

·         Vitamin D Supplement

·         Vitamin E Supplement

·         Niacin

·         D-Calcium Pantothenic

·         Thiamine Mononitrate

·         Riboflavin Supplement

·         Pyrrolidone Hydrochloride

·         Folic Acid

·         Source of Vitamin K Activity

·         Biotin

·         Vitamin B12 Supplement

·         Inositol

·         L-Tryptophan

Probiotics

·         Enterococcus Faecium


N/A

You’ll notice that whole, fresh, freeze-dried, or dehydrated animal ingredients, as well as carefully selected nutrient-dense plant ingredients, are capable of filling the role of the synthetic nutrients used in the vegan alternative.

Both of the diets compared meet AAFCO standards, but only one sources it’s nutrients entirely from real food ingredients. If this was made for humans, which would you rather put in your body?

The Takeaways

cat-sitting-vegetables

This may be an unpopular opinion, but feeding your cat a vegan diet is possible, so long as the food is nutritionally balanced using man-made nutrients to fill the gaps that animal products would typically fill.

Are they perfectly equal? In our opinion, no, but that’s not the question we are here to answer. We came to examine whether or not cats can be omnivorous.

We know that they are not omnivores, but also determined that a plant-based diet can, at least on paper, meet their basic nutritional needs.

What’s important to remember is that veganism is an inherently human choice; it’s up to you to decide whether you apply your human ideals to your pet.

Here’s an interesting perspective from a vegan advocacy website that might help provide some perspective: Vegan Cat Food: The Cold Hard Truth

If you decide to apply your vegan lifestyle to your pets, we recommend talking with your vet first and doing a lot of research when selecting a brand or recipe. Some brands, like Vecado, put a lot of time and research into balancing the nutrients in their formulas, but that doesn’t apply to every formulation or recipe you find on the internet.

Nutritionally unbalanced diets can lead to serious, long-term consequences. This applies to both meat-based and plant-based cat foods. Look beyond the packaging and eye-catching claims, and dig into what’s really in your pet’s food.

Make sure you are monitoring their health closely. A vegan diet may work well for some cats, while others will thrive on a carnivorous diet. In the end, the health of your cat is the most important factor, so make decisions that keep them healthy and thriving.

Do you feed your cat like a carnivore or an omnivore? Have you had success in feeding a plant-based cat diet? Let us know your thoughts on vegan cat foods in the comments below.


Posted by Krystn Janisse

Krystn is a passionate pet nutrition enthusiast. She has worked in the pet industry for over a decade and loves to share her passion for animal welfare with others. She loves all animals but is currently channelling some crazy cat lady vibes with her five lovable, but rebellious cats.


Get Future Pet Articles in Your Inbox?

Get our latest articles delivered directly to your email inbox.